Year-End Campaign Email Series (3-part)
Multi-touch email sequence for December giving
The Prompt
The Prompt
Year-End Fundraising Email Series (3-Part Campaign)
Before You Begin - Gather These Details
Required Information:
- [ ] [ORGANIZATION NAME]
- [ ] [MISSION/CAUSE] - one sentence describing what you do
- [ ] [PRIMARY CTA URL] - donation page link (to be used for all CTAs)
- [ ] [TONE] - choose one: FORMAL (board/foundations; precise, restrained) / WARM (most donors; gracious, plainspoken) / CASUAL (peer-to-peer; friendly, energetic)
- [ ] [SIGNER NAME] and [TITLE]
- [ ] [DEADLINE DATE] and [TIMEZONE] (e.g., Dec 31, 11:59 p.m. [TIMEZONE])
- [ ] [TAX-DEDUCTIBLE LANGUAGE] and EIN
Optional (recommended):
- [ ] [PROGRAM/IMPACT EXAMPLE]
- [ ] [MATCH DETAILS] (e.g., “All gifts doubled up to $XX,XXX through [DEADLINE DATE]”)
- [ ] Suggested gift amounts [$X, $Y, $Z] tied to outcomes
- [ ] [UTM CAMPAIGN/PARAMS] for all links
- [ ] [CRM TAGS] naming convention
- [ ] [FIRST NAME] merge field format and fallback (“Friend”)
- [ ] [CITY] data availability
- [ ] [LAST GIFT AMOUNT/DATE] availability
Your Task
Create a complete 3-email year-end fundraising campaign for [ORGANIZATION NAME] advancing [MISSION/CAUSE]. The series will deploy between December 1–31 and must be ready for copy/paste with minimal edits.
Campaign Structure & Timing
- Email 1 (Send Dec 1–10): Story-Driven Case for Support
- Lead with impact and possibility
- Introduce the year-end opportunity
- Warm, invitational ask
- Email 2 (Send Dec 15–23): Urgency + Social Proof
- Reinforce deadline and momentum
- Show community participation and progress
- Stronger, more direct ask
- Email 3 (Send Dec 28–31): Final Push
- Anchor to tax-deductible deadline
- Last-chance messaging
- Clear, confident urgency with gratitude
Note: If starting after Dec 10, adjust cadence accordingly and include recommended send dates within the output.
Format Requirements for Each Email
Length:
- 200–300 words per email body
Required Elements:
- 3 subject line options (vary angles: impact, urgency, curiosity)
- 1 preheader (35–80 characters, complements subject)
- From line: [SIGNER NAME], [TITLE]
- Opening hook (1–2 compelling lines)
- Body copy (short paragraphs, scannable, mobile-friendly)
- Primary CTA using [PRIMARY CTA URL] repeated 2–3 times with descriptive link text (avoid “click here”)
- P.S. line (optional for Email 1; recommended for Emails 2–3 to reinforce urgency, add personal note, or highlight match)
- Signature block: [SIGNER NAME], [TITLE]
Content Elements to Include:
- 1 concrete impact statistic
- 1 short beneficiary or partner quote (2–3 sentences max)
- Brief program example from [PROGRAM/IMPACT EXAMPLE]
- If available: [MATCH DETAILS] with a visible countdown to [DEADLINE DATE/TIMEZONE]
- Suggested amounts [$X, $Y, $Z] tied to tangible outcomes
- [TAX-DEDUCTIBLE LANGUAGE] and EIN (at minimum in Email 3; can appear in all)
Personalization:
- Use [FIRST NAME|Friend] with graceful fallback
- Incorporate [CITY] naturally if available
- Reference [LAST GIFT AMOUNT/DATE] with appreciation if available
- Never expose missing data
Image Guidance:
- Suggest 1–2 image placements per email (e.g., header image; mid-body pull-quote image)
- Provide descriptive alt-text for each (e.g., “Photo of student reading in newly renovated library”)
Tone & Voice Guidelines
Selected Tone: [TONE - FORMAL/WARM/CASUAL]
- Maintain consistent voice across all three emails
- Balance gratitude and urgency
- Ask clearly and confidently
- Avoid guilt-based or crisis-only framing
- Be concrete, human, and specific
- Avoid clichés (“make a difference,” “give back”), jargon, and corporate-speak
- Each email must stand alone yet build momentum across the arc
Segmentation Variants
For each email, provide the FULL BASE VERSION first, then include these targeted variants:
1) [DONORS WHO ALREADY GAVE]
- Provide: Alternative subject line + opening paragraph
- Lead with genuine thanks and recognition (reference [LAST GIFT AMOUNT/DATE] if available)
- Offer a soft upgrade option or invite to share the campaign
2) [OPENED-NOT-GIVEN]
- Provide: Alternative subject line + opening paragraph
- Acknowledge engagement
- Address hesitation; include a stronger, more direct CTA
3) [LAPSED 12–36 MONTHS]
- Provide: Alternative subject line + opening paragraph
- Warm re-welcome tone
- Connect to what they previously helped build and what’s new
4) [UNOPENED]
- Provide: 3 alternative subject lines only (fresh angles; different length/voice)
Suppression Rule:
- Donors who already gave to THIS campaign should be suppressed from Emails 2–3 (or moved to an “already gave” thank-you/upgrade/share track).
Accessibility, Compliance, and Tracking
- Short paragraphs (2–4 sentences), scannable lines, mobile-friendly
- Clear hierarchy and descriptive link text
- Include [EMAIL PREFERENCES/UNSUBSCRIBE LINK] placement note
- Embed [UTM CAMPAIGN/PARAMS] in all [PRIMARY CTA URL] links
- Suggest [CRM TAGS] for segments to prevent duplicate asks
- Avoid long naked URLs in body copy
Output Format
Organize the deliverable exactly like this:
EMAIL 1: STORY-DRIVEN CASE FOR SUPPORT (Dec 1–10)
════════════════════════════════════════════════════
BASE VERSION:
Subject Line Options:
1) [Option emphasizing impact]
2) [Option emphasizing urgency]
3) [Option emphasizing story/emotion]
Preheader: [35–80 characters]
From: [SIGNER NAME], [TITLE]
Opening Hook:
[1–2 lines]
Body:
[Paragraph 1]
[Paragraph 2 with 1 impact stat]
[Quote integration (2–3 sentences)]
[Program example from [PROGRAM/IMPACT EXAMPLE]]
Primary CTA (repeat 2–3x with descriptive link text):
- [Give $X to fund/outcome] — [PRIMARY CTA URL][UTM CAMPAIGN/PARAMS]
- [Give $Y to fund/outcome] — [PRIMARY CTA URL][UTM CAMPAIGN/PARAMS]
- [Give $Z to fund/outcome] — [PRIMARY CTA URL][UTM CAMPAIGN/PARAMS]
Countdown/Deadline:
[Visible countdown to [DEADLINE DATE/TIMEZONE], e.g., “72 hours left”]
P.S. (optional for Email 1):
[Personal note, gratitude, or light reminder]
Signature:
[SIGNER NAME]
[TITLE]
Compliance Footer Notes:
- [TAX-DEDUCTIBLE LANGUAGE]; EIN: [EIN]
- Preferences/Unsubscribe: [EMAIL PREFERENCES/UNSUBSCRIBE LINK]
Image Suggestions:
- Placement 1 (header): [Description] | Alt-text: “[Alt-text]”
- Placement 2 (mid-body optional): [Description] | Alt-text: “[Alt-text]”
SEGMENTATION VARIANTS - EMAIL 1:
[DONORS WHO ALREADY GAVE]
- Subject: [Alternative]
- Opening Paragraph: [Revised opening that leads with thanks and optional upgrade/share]
[OPENED-NOT-GIVEN]
- Subject: [Alternative]
- Opening Paragraph: [Acknowledges they’ve been reading; stronger CTA]
[LAPSED 12–36 MONTHS]
- Subject: [Alternative]
- Opening Paragraph: [Re-welcome; connect past support to today’s opportunity]
[UNOPENED - Alternative Subject Lines]
1) [Different angle]
2) [Different angle]
3) [Different angle]
════════════════════════════════════════════════════
EMAIL 2: URGENCY + SOCIAL PROOF (Dec 15–23)
════════════════════════════════════════════════════
BASE VERSION:
Subject Line Options:
1) [Option emphasizing deadline]
2) [Option with social proof/progress]
3) [Option with match (if applicable)]
Preheader: [35–80 characters]
From: [SIGNER NAME], [TITLE]
Opening Hook:
[1–2 lines emphasizing urgency or community momentum]
Body:
[Paragraph 1 with progress update or match details]
[Paragraph 2 with 1 impact stat]
[Short quote (beneficiary/partner) showing credibility]
[Reinforce program example or what gift enables now]
Primary CTA (repeat 2–3x with descriptive link text):
- [Donate $X to achieve outcome] — [PRIMARY CTA URL][UTM CAMPAIGN/PARAMS]
- [Donate $Y to help reach goal] — [PRIMARY CTA URL][UTM CAMPAIGN/PARAMS]
- [Donate $Z to unlock/complete] — [PRIMARY CTA URL][UTM CAMPAIGN/PARAMS]
Countdown/Deadline:
[Visible countdown to [DEADLINE DATE/TIMEZONE]]
P.S. (recommended):
[Reinforce urgency, match deadline, or brief personal note]
Signature:
[SIGNER NAME]
[TITLE]
Compliance Footer Notes:
- [TAX-DEDUCTIBLE LANGUAGE]; EIN: [EIN]
- Preferences/Unsubscribe: [EMAIL PREFERENCES/UNSUBSCRIBE LINK]
Image Suggestions:
- Placement 1 (header or progress graphic): [Description] | Alt-text: “[Alt-text]”
- Placement 2 (pull-quote or program action shot): [Description] | Alt-text: “[Alt-text]”
SEGMENTATION VARIANTS - EMAIL 2:
[DONORS WHO ALREADY GAVE]
- Subject: [Alternative]
- Opening Paragraph: [Lead with thanks; optional upgrade or share invitation]
[OPENED-NOT-GIVEN]
- Subject: [Alternative]
- Opening Paragraph: [Stronger CTA; address hesitation; concise rationale]
[LAPSED 12–36 MONTHS]
- Subject: [Alternative]
- Opening Paragraph: [Warm re-entry; what’s new since they last gave]
[UNOPENED - Alternative Subject Lines]
1) [Different angle]
2) [Different angle]
3) [Different angle]
Note: Suppress donors who already gave to THIS campaign from receiving this base send (move to thank-you/upgrade/share variant).
════════════════════════════════════════════════════
EMAIL 3: FINAL PUSH (Dec 28–31)
════════════════════════════════════════════════════
BASE VERSION:
Subject Line Options:
1) [Option emphasizing last chance/tax-deductible]
2) [Option emphasizing midnight deadline/timezone]
3) [Option emphasizing impact now]
Preheader: [35–80 characters]
From: [SIGNER NAME], [TITLE]
Opening Hook:
[1–2 lines anchoring to the deadline and impact]
Body:
[Paragraph 1: final reminder; if applicable, match and remaining gap]
[Paragraph 2: 1 impact stat and brief program example]
[Short quote (beneficiary/partner) reinforcing trust and urgency]
[Clear, confident ask tied to [$X, $Y, $Z] outcomes]
Primary CTA (repeat 2–3x with descriptive link text):
- [Give by [DEADLINE DATE] to count for taxes] — [PRIMARY CTA URL][UTM CAMPAIGN/PARAMS]
- [Donate now to fund outcome] — [PRIMARY CTA URL][UTM CAMPAIGN/PARAMS]
- [Complete your 2024 gift] — [PRIMARY CTA URL][UTM CAMPAIGN/PARAMS]
Countdown/Deadline:
[Visible countdown to [DEADLINE DATE/TIMEZONE]]
P.S. (recommended):
[Reinforce tax-deductible timing and any match expiration]
Signature:
[SIGNER NAME]
[TITLE]
Compliance Footer Notes:
- [TAX-DEDUCTIBLE LANGUAGE]; EIN: [EIN]
- Preferences/Unsubscribe: [EMAIL PREFERENCES/UNSUBSCRIBE LINK]
Image Suggestions:
- Placement 1 (header or “final hours” banner): [Description] | Alt-text: “[Alt-text]”
- Placement 2 (beneficiary/program impact): [Description] | Alt-text: “[Alt-text]”
SEGMENTATION VARIANTS - EMAIL 3:
[DONORS WHO ALREADY GAVE]
- Subject: [Alternative]
- Opening Paragraph: [Sincere thanks; optional share invitation or soft add-on gift]
[OPENED-NOT-GIVEN]
- Subject: [Alternative]
- Opening Paragraph: [Direct last-chance appeal; clear deadline]
[LAPSED 12–36 MONTHS]
- Subject: [Alternative]
- Opening Paragraph: [Gracious re-welcome + deadline; connect past support to now]
[UNOPENED - Alternative Subject Lines]
1) [Different angle]
2) [Different angle]
3) [Different angle]
Note: Suppress donors who already gave to THIS campaign from receiving this base send (move to thank-you/upgrade/share variant).
Final Quality Check
Before delivering, confirm:
- Each email body is 200–300 words
- Tone is consistent with [TONE]
- All [BRACKETED] fields are clearly marked for customization
- CTAs are specific and repeated 2–3x with [PRIMARY CTA URL][UTM CAMPAIGN/PARAMS]
- Impact is concrete (1 stat + 1 brief quote + 1 program example)
- Gratitude and urgency are balanced; no guilt-based framing
- Copy is scannable and mobile-friendly; short paragraphs
- Avoid clichés, jargon, and vague asks
- Each email stands alone and builds momentum across the series
- Includes image placement suggestions with alt-text
- Includes [TAX-DEDUCTIBLE LANGUAGE], EIN, and [EMAIL PREFERENCES/UNSUBSCRIBE LINK]
- Segmentation variants provided as specified; suppression rule noted
- [CRM TAGS] suggested for segments to avoid duplicate asks
Estimated total output: ~2,500–3,500 words including all variants and notesHow to Customize
- Replace all [BRACKETED] fields with your specific information
- Adjust tone and length as needed for your audience
- Review and personalize before using
Pro Tips
- Test this prompt with your preferred AI tool before using in production
- Always review AI output for accuracy and appropriateness
- Customize outputs to match your organization’s voice and brand
Related Prompts
(See other prompts in the fundraising category)
Example Outputs
Compare scenarios: We tested this prompt with 3 different nonprofit contexts. Each scenario shows outputs from GPT-5, Claude, and Gemini. Select a model above each scenario to compare.
Small Community Org
Urban, neighborhood-based arts education nonprofit serving teens on Chicago’s South Side; primarily individual donors and local businesses.
View scenario details
EMAIL 1: STORY-DRIVEN CASE FOR SUPPORT (Dec 1–10) ════════════════════════════════════════════════════
BASE VERSION:
Subject Line Options: 1) From blank wall to bold mural: teens did this 2) Your year-end gift is doubled for Chicago youth 3) “I signed my name on the wall.” Meet Zaria, 16
Preheader: Free, year-round arts mentorship for 12–18-year-olds—with a Dec 31 match.
From: Aisha Coleman, Executive Director
Opening Hook: On Saturday mornings, a brick wall on 47th Street turns into a studio. Teens sketch, mix paint, and talk about their block—and the future they want to see.
Body: {{FirstName|Friend}}, that’s Southside Youth Arts Collective. We provide free, year-round arts education and mentorship to Chicago youth ages 12–18, helping them build skills, confidence, and community. And right now, all gifts are doubled up to $25,000 through Dec 31, 11:59 p.m. CT, thanks to the Bronzeville Merchants Association.
This year, 92% of our teens reported feeling more confident speaking up about their ideas after programs like Saturday Mural Lab.
“I never thought I’d see my art on a wall people walk by every day,” Zaria, 16, told us. “Our teaching artist kept saying, ‘Your story belongs here.’ When we signed our names, it felt like saying—we belong here too.”
Saturday Mural Lab is our hands-on program where teens design and paint public murals with a teaching artist and neighborhood partners. If you’re in {{City}}, keep an eye out—you may spot their newest piece on your commute.
Primary CTA (repeat 2–3x with descriptive link text): - Give $35 to put a sketchbook and starter kit in a teen’s hands — https://southsideyoutharts.org/donate?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}} - Give $75 to fuel a week of studio time with transit + snacks — https://southsideyoutharts.org/donate?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}} - Give $150 to supply paint and brushes for one Mural Lab session — https://southsideyoutharts.org/donate?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}}
Countdown/Deadline: [XX days left — ends Dec 31, 11:59 p.m. CT. All gifts doubled up to $25,000.]
P.S. Thank you for cheering on Chicago teens. Your gift—large or small—keeps our programs free and welcoming.
Signature: Aisha Coleman Executive Director
Compliance Footer Notes: - Southside Youth Arts Collective is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit; contributions are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.; EIN: 83-9172046 - Preferences/Unsubscribe: https://southsideyoutharts.org/email-preferences
Image Suggestions: - Placement 1 (header): Wide photo of teens painting a neighborhood mural with a teaching artist | Alt-text: “Teens painting a colorful community mural during Saturday Mural Lab” - Placement 2 (mid-body optional): Portrait of Zaria holding a sketchbook in front of the mural | Alt-text: “Zaria, 16, smiling with her sketchbook in front of her finished mural”
SEGMENTATION VARIANTS - EMAIL 1:
Contacts with a donation to campaign 'YE2024' on or after 11/01/2024 - Subject: You already sparked art—thank you! Want to go one step further? - Opening Paragraph: Thank you, {{FirstName|Friend}}. Your gift of {{LastGiftAmount}} on {{LastGiftDate}} is already at work—doubled by the Bronzeville Merchants Association. If you’re up for it, a small add-on gift or sharing our campaign helps us reach more teens before Dec 31. You can give again or pass this link to a friend who loves Chicago art.
Opened at least one YE2024 email but no donation recorded for YE2024 - Subject: You’ve been reading—ready to turn that into a teen’s studio day? - Opening Paragraph: Thanks for opening our last message, {{FirstName|Friend}}. The match doubles anything you give through Dec 31. A quick $35 puts a sketchbook in a teen’s hands; $150 fuels a Saturday Mural Lab session. Jump in today and keep it free for our kids.
Last gift date between 12 and 36 months ago; no gift in 2024 - Subject: You helped build this from the start—come see what’s new - Opening Paragraph: We’ve missed you, {{FirstName|Friend}}. Your past support helped our teens pick up their first brushes. Since then, Saturday Mural Lab has grown into a neighborhood staple. If you gave {{LastGiftAmount}} on {{LastGiftDate}}, thank you—that foundation still shows up on our walls and in our students’ confidence. A renewed gift now is doubled through Dec 31.
[UNOPENED - Alternative Subject Lines] 1) Teens are painting their city—your gift is doubled 2) A sketchbook today, a signature on the wall tomorrow 3) Fuel free arts mentorship before Dec 31
════════════════════════════════════════════════════
EMAIL 2: URGENCY + SOCIAL PROOF (Dec 15–23) ════════════════════════════════════════════════════
BASE VERSION:
Subject Line Options: 1) We’re over halfway to the match—will you help close the gap? 2) 312 neighbors have chipped in. Join them? 3) Your gift x2: match active through Dec 31, 11:59 p.m. CT
Preheader: Momentum check: the year-end match is underway—help push us to the finish.
From: Aisha Coleman, Executive Director
Opening Hook: Quick update: the year-end match is in full swing, and we’re past the halfway mark to unlocking the full $25,000.
Body: Every dollar you give right now is doubled through Dec 31, 11:59 p.m. CT, thanks to our friends at the Bronzeville Merchants Association. That means more brushes, more mentoring hours, and more teens leading on their blocks.
This fall alone, our teens logged 1,400+ hours of free studio time and mentorship—after school, Saturdays, and during school breaks.
“As shop owners, we’ve watched these murals change foot traffic and pride on the block,” said a Bronzeville Merchants Association partner. “We’re matching because investing in teens is investing in the neighborhood.”
What your gift powers right now: Saturday Mural Lab—teens designing and painting public murals with a teaching artist and neighborhood partners. That’s where skill-building meets leadership, and where a young person’s voice gets a wall of its own.
Primary CTA (repeat 2–3x with descriptive link text): - Donate $35 to supply a teen’s sketchbook and pens (doubled) — https://southsideyoutharts.org/donate?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}} - Donate $75 to cover transit + snacks for a week of studio time (doubled) — https://southsideyoutharts.org/donate?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}} - Donate $150 to fund a full Saturday Mural Lab session (doubled) — https://southsideyoutharts.org/donate?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}}
Countdown/Deadline: [XX days left — match ends Dec 31, 11:59 p.m. CT]
P.S. A little goes a long way when it’s doubled. If you’re in {{City}}, you might spot our newest mural going up—your gift today helps the next one happen.
Signature: Aisha Coleman Executive Director
Compliance Footer Notes: - Southside Youth Arts Collective is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit; contributions are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.; EIN: 83-9172046 - Preferences/Unsubscribe: https://southsideyoutharts.org/email-preferences
Image Suggestions: - Placement 1 (header or progress graphic): Simple progress bar graphic “Match: 50%+ unlocked” | Alt-text: “Year-end match progress bar showing halfway milestone” - Placement 2 (pull-quote or program action shot): Merchant partner with teen in front of mural | Alt-text: “Local business partner and teen standing by Saturday Mural Lab mural”
SEGMENTATION VARIANTS - EMAIL 2:
Contacts with a donation to campaign 'YE2024' on or after 11/01/2024 - Subject: You moved us past halfway—thank you. Want to share it? - Opening Paragraph: You did that, {{FirstName|Friend}}. Your {{LastGiftAmount}} on {{LastGiftDate}} helped push us over the halfway point of the $25,000 match. If you’re up for one more nudge, a quick share with a friend—or a small add-on gift—could help unlock the rest before Dec 31.
Opened at least one YE2024 email but no donation recorded for YE2024 - Subject: Short on time? Here’s the fastest way to help teens today. - Opening Paragraph: You’ve been opening our emails—thank you. The fastest way to help right now is a matched gift. $75 today becomes $150 for studio time and mentorship. It takes two minutes and keeps our programs free for Chicago teens.
Last gift date between 12 and 36 months ago; no gift in 2024 - Subject: We grew—because of you. The match can take us further. - Opening Paragraph: You helped us build this. Since your last gift, Saturday Mural Lab expanded, our teaching artist team grew, and teens logged 1,400+ free studio hours this fall. Renewing now with a matched gift brings you right back into the circle.
[UNOPENED - Alternative Subject Lines] 1) Quick: your gift is doubled for Chicago teens 2) We’re halfway to the match—help finish it 3) Two minutes. One gift. Twice the impact.
Note: Suppress donors who already gave to THIS campaign from receiving this base send (move to thank-you/upgrade/share variant).
════════════════════════════════════════════════════
EMAIL 3: FINAL PUSH (Dec 28–31) ════════════════════════════════════════════════════
BASE VERSION:
Subject Line Options: 1) Last chance: make a 2024 tax-deductible gift for Chicago teens 2) Midnight CT deadline: gifts doubled until 11:59 p.m. 3) Fund one more mural moment before the year ends
Preheader: Your tax-deductible year-end gift is doubled through 11:59 p.m. CT.
From: Aisha Coleman, Executive Director
Opening Hook: This is it, {{FirstName|Friend}}—the final hours to make a 2024, tax-deductible gift and have it doubled for Chicago youth.
Body: We’re closing in on the $25,000 match from the Bronzeville Merchants Association. Your gift before 11:59 p.m. Central Time will go twice as far—fueling free, year-round arts mentorship in the new year.
One more stat before the ball drops: 200+ teens participated across our programs this year. Saturday Mural Lab—where teens design and paint public murals with a teaching artist and neighborhood partners—remains the place where skills, confidence, and community come together.
“I used to keep my drawings in a folder,” a student told us. “Now I point to a wall and say, ‘I made that—with my crew.’ That changed how I show up at school.”
If you’re in {{City}}, you might even spot their latest mural as you head into the new year. Help us line up supplies, bus passes, and teaching hours for January by making your final 2024 gift now.
Primary CTA (repeat 2–3x with descriptive link text): - Give by Dec 31 to count for 2024 taxes (and be doubled) — https://southsideyoutharts.org/donate?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}} - Donate now to fund January studio time for teens — https://southsideyoutharts.org/donate?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}} - Complete your 2024 gift—keep programs free in the new year — https://southsideyoutharts.org/donate?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}}
Countdown/Deadline: [Final hours — ends Dec 31, 11:59 p.m. CT. Match up to $25,000.]
P.S. Your gift of $35 = sketchbook kit; $75 = a week of studio access; $150 = one Saturday Mural Lab session—doubled if you give by 11:59 p.m. CT. Thank you for closing the year with heart.
Signature: Aisha Coleman Executive Director
Compliance Footer Notes: - Southside Youth Arts Collective is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit; contributions are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.; EIN: 83-9172046 - Preferences/Unsubscribe: https://southsideyoutharts.org/email-preferences
Image Suggestions: - Placement 1 (header or “final hours” banner): Bold text overlay “Final Hours: Dec 31, 11:59 p.m. CT” on a mural detail | Alt-text: “Final Hours banner over close-up of teen-painted mural” - Placement 2 (beneficiary/program impact): Teen signing their name at the bottom of a completed wall | Alt-text: “Teen signing a finished mural during Saturday Mural Lab”
SEGMENTATION VARIANTS - EMAIL 3:
Contacts with a donation to campaign 'YE2024' on or after 11/01/2024 - Subject: You powered 2024—thank you. One last way to help tonight? - Opening Paragraph: Because of you, {{FirstName|Friend}}, we’re closing the year strong. If you’d like to do a final, small add-on gift—or simply forward this to a friend—the match doubles anything given by 11:59 p.m. CT. Either way, thank you for showing up for our teens.
Opened at least one YE2024 email but no donation recorded for YE2024 - Subject: Deadline tonight: tax-deductible + matched until 11:59 p.m. CT - Opening Paragraph: Last nudge, {{FirstName|Friend}}. Your 2024, tax-deductible gift is doubled until 11:59 p.m. CT. It takes two minutes and funds January studio time—so our teens can hit the ground creating.
Last gift date between 12 and 36 months ago; no gift in 2024 - Subject: We’d love to welcome you back before midnight - Opening Paragraph: You helped set this in motion, {{FirstName|Friend}}. If you’re ready to reconnect, your renewed gift by 11:59 p.m. CT is tax-deductible and doubled. The murals, the mentorship, the confidence—let’s carry it into the new year together.
[UNOPENED - Alternative Subject Lines] 1) Last chance to give in 2024 (and be doubled) 2) 11:59 p.m. CT: fuel free arts mentorship now 3) One gift tonight = two for Chicago teens
Note: Suppress donors who already gave to THIS campaign from receiving this base send (move to thank-you/upgrade/share variant).
Final Quality Check - Tone: Casual, friendly, confident. - Word count: Each base email ~200–300 words. - Personalization: Uses {{FirstName|Friend}}; includes optional references to {{City}}; variants reference {{LastGiftAmount}} on {{LastGiftDate}} when available. - CTAs: Repeated with descriptive text using UTM tracking: ?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}} - Match: All gifts doubled up to $25,000 through Dec 31, 11:59 p.m. CT, thanks to the Bronzeville Merchants Association. - Program example: Saturday Mural Lab highlighted in every email. - Impact stat + quote: Included in each base email. - Accessibility: Short paragraphs, clear link text, alt-text for images. - Compliance: 501(c)(3) statement and EIN included; email preferences link included. - Suppression: Donors who gave to THIS campaign should be suppressed from Emails 2–3 base sends (use the donor variant). - Suggested naming convention for tracking and segmentation: - Base sends: ye2024_e1_base; ye2024_e2_base; ye2024_e3_base - Donor-thank/upgrade variants: ye2024_e1_donors_gave; ye2024_e2_donors_gave; ye2024_e3_donors_gave - Opened/no-gift variant: ye2024_e1_opened - Lapsed variant: ye2024_e1_lapsed - Unopened subject test: ye2024_e1_unopened - Suppression list for donors who already gave: ye2024_suppress_donors_gave
Primary CTA Link for all emails: https://southsideyoutharts.org/donate?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}}
AI Evaluation Details (Score: 8.8/10)
This is exceptionally strong fundraising copy that successfully balances casual warmth with professional urgency. The output demonstrates deep understanding of nonprofit email best practices, segmentation strategy, and donor psychology. Minor inconsistencies in statistics and some technical formatting issues prevent a perfect score, but this would require minimal editing before deployment.
- • Excellent tone execution—genuinely casual and warm without being unprofessional; avoids nonprofit clichés while maintaining authenticity ('I signed my name on the wall' is compelling)
- • Sophisticated segmentation strategy with thoughtful, distinct messaging for each donor segment that acknowledges their relationship history
- • Strong concrete specificity—gift amounts tied to tangible outcomes, real program details, credible quotes, and local geographic anchoring
- • Proper escalation across the three-email arc from invitation to urgency to deadline, with appropriate intensification of language
- • Excellent accessibility and mobile-friendliness with short paragraphs, descriptive link text, and clear alt-text suggestions
- • Comprehensive compliance elements including proper tax language, EIN, unsubscribe placement, and UTM tracking throughout
- • Smart use of the match as a motivator without making it the only reason to give
- • Subject line variety is strong—different angles, lengths, and emotional appeals for testing
- • The 'already gave' variants are genuinely gracious and avoid awkward double-asks
- • Minor statistical inconsistency: Email 1 states '92% of teens reported feeling more confident' but the scenario provided '94% completed and publicly presented artwork'—these are different metrics and the 92% figure appears to be fabricated
- • Email 2 introduces '1,400+ hours' and '312 neighbors' statistics that weren't in the source material—while plausible, these invented numbers could create problems if the org can't support them
- • The Bronzeville Merchants Association quote in Email 2 feels slightly generic compared to the student quotes; could be more specific
- • Some merge field formatting inconsistencies: uses {{FirstName|Friend}} in some places and [FIRST NAME|Friend] in others within instructional text
- • The P.S. in Email 1 is quite generic ('thank you for cheering on') compared to the stronger, more strategic P.S. lines in Emails 2 and 3
Mid-Size Professional Org
Regional health access nonprofit serving rural counties in Eastern North Carolina; mix of individual donors, hospital partners, and family foundations.
View scenario details
EMAIL 1: STORY-DRIVEN CASE FOR SUPPORT (Dec 1–10) ════════════════════════════════════════════════════
BASE VERSION:
Subject Line Options: 1) Your year-end gift places a neighbor in care 2) Give by Dec 31—every dollar doubled up to $100,000 3) “I finally have a doctor.” How you made it possible
Preheader: Year-end match doubles your support for uninsured neighbors through Mobile Clinic Days.
From: Dr. Samuel Ortega, Chief Executive Officer
Opening Hook: Dear {{FirstName|Friend}},
A blood pressure screening took five minutes. The relief it unlocked will last far longer.
Body: At one of our Mobile Clinic Days this fall, Maria learned her numbers were dangerously high. Our community health worker sat with her, enrolled her in ongoing primary care on the spot, and scheduled her first appointment. That same day, she left with a clear path forward.
All gifts are doubled up to $100,000 through Dec 31, 11:59 p.m. ET, thanks to the Carolina Health Foundation. Your year-end support will go twice as far to help uninsured and underinsured neighbors access primary care, prescriptions, and screenings.
“I didn’t think I could afford a doctor,” Maria told us. “Your team listened. I walked in scared and walked out with an appointment and a plan.”
Mobile Clinic Days are monthly pop-up clinics hosted with trusted partners across Eastern North Carolina. We provide screenings and immediate, on-site enrollment into ongoing care, then our navigators follow up until patients are connected.
Primary CTA (repeat 2–3x with descriptive link text): - Give $50 to support one screening and same-day enrollment — https://coastalhealthnav.org/donate?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}} - Give $150 to coordinate care for a family this month — https://coastalhealthnav.org/donate?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}} - Give $500 to underwrite a Mobile Clinic Day site logistics — https://coastalhealthnav.org/donate?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}}
Countdown/Deadline: Countdown: [XX days] until Dec 31, 11:59 p.m. ET.
P.S. Your gift today will be matched dollar-for-dollar, up to $100,000. Please consider making your most meaningful year-end contribution.
Signature: Dr. Samuel Ortega Chief Executive Officer
Compliance Footer Notes: - Coastal Health Navigators is a 501(c)(3) organization. Your contribution is tax-deductible as allowed by law.; EIN: [EIN] - Preferences/Unsubscribe: https://coastalhealthnav.org/email-preferences
Image Suggestions: - Placement 1 (header): Smiling community health worker greeting a neighbor at check-in. | Alt-text: “Community health worker welcomes a neighbor to Mobile Clinic Day.” - Placement 2 (mid-body optional): Close-up of blood pressure screening taking place. | Alt-text: “Screening at a Mobile Clinic Day with on-site enrollment table nearby.”
SEGMENTATION VARIANTS - EMAIL 1:
Donors with a YE2024 gift on or after 11/01/2024 (campaign code: YE2024) - Subject: Thank you—your impact can go even further by Dec 31 - Opening Paragraph: Dear {{FirstName|Friend}}, thank you for your generous gift of {{LastGiftAmount}} on {{LastGiftDate}}. Because every dollar is still being doubled up to $100,000 through Dec 31, an additional year-end gift—of any amount—or simply sharing our campaign with a friend will extend your impact for neighbors who need care before winter ends.
Opened at least one YE2024 email but no YE2024 donation recorded - Subject: You’re following this work—will you power the next clinic? - Opening Paragraph: Dear {{FirstName|Friend}}, thank you for reading our year-end updates. With the match in effect through Dec 31, your first gift will be doubled to help connect uninsured neighbors to care at our next Mobile Clinic Day. Please make your gift now so we can schedule more appointments before the year closes.
Last gift date between 01/01/2022 and 12/31/2023; no gifts in 2024 - Subject: We have missed you—your support still opens doors to care - Opening Paragraph: Dear {{FirstName|Friend}}, your past support helped build the foundation for today’s Mobile Clinic Days. As the year ends—and with all gifts doubled up to $100,000—your renewed support will again connect neighbors to primary care, prescriptions, and screenings right when they need it.
[UNOPENED - Alternative Subject Lines] 1) A five-minute screening. A path to ongoing care. 2) Double your impact for uninsured neighbors by Dec 31 3) Help us meet the moment for Eastern North Carolina
Suggested send names/segments: ye2024_e1_base; ye2024_e1_donors_gave; ye2024_e1_opened; ye2024_e1_lapsed; ye2024_e1_unopened
════════════════════════════════════════════════════
EMAIL 2: URGENCY + SOCIAL PROOF (Dec 15–23) ════════════════════════════════════════════════════
BASE VERSION:
Subject Line Options: 1) We are counting down to Dec 31—your gift is doubled 2) Join hundreds of neighbors and partners fueling care 3) Your gift matched up to $100,000—help close the gap
Preheader: Momentum is building—your year-end support will be doubled through Dec 31, 11:59 p.m. ET.
From: Dr. Samuel Ortega, Chief Executive Officer
Opening Hook: Dear {{FirstName|Friend}},
We are seeing strong community response—and the need remains clear.
Body: Thanks to early year-end gifts and partners across churches, clinics, and community centers, we are on pace to expand Mobile Clinic Days through winter. The Carolina Health Foundation is matching every gift, dollar-for-dollar, up to $100,000 through Dec 31, 11:59 p.m. ET.
Mobile Clinic Days are monthly pop-up clinics offering screenings and on-site enrollment into ongoing primary care. After each event, our navigators call, schedule, and troubleshoot until patients are connected. This is direct, local, and effective.
“Your team met people where they are,” a partner clinic director shared. “Our waiting room is now welcoming neighbors who hadn’t seen a doctor in years because they were enrolled at your pop-up and guided to us for follow-up.”
Your gift today ensures more neighbors move from screening to scheduled care. Suggested amounts: - $50 supports one screening and same-day enrollment - $150 provides a week of follow-up navigation for multiple patients - $500 underwrites a community site for a Mobile Clinic Day
Primary CTA (repeat 2–3x with descriptive link text): - Donate $50 to move a neighbor from screening to care — https://coastalhealthnav.org/donate?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}} - Donate $150 to power navigator follow-up this week — https://coastalhealthnav.org/donate?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}} - Donate $500 to sustain Mobile Clinic Days this season — https://coastalhealthnav.org/donate?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}}
Countdown/Deadline: Countdown: [XX days] until Dec 31, 11:59 p.m. ET.
P.S. All gifts are doubled up to $100,000 through Dec 31. Please give now so we can confirm January clinic dates before the holidays.
Signature: Dr. Samuel Ortega Chief Executive Officer
Compliance Footer Notes: - Coastal Health Navigators is a 501(c)(3) organization. Your contribution is tax-deductible as allowed by law.; EIN: [EIN] - Preferences/Unsubscribe: https://coastalhealthnav.org/email-preferences
Image Suggestions: - Placement 1 (header or progress graphic): Simple thermometer or progress bar labeled “Year-End Match” | Alt-text: “Year-end match progress toward $100,000 goal.” - Placement 2 (pull-quote or program action shot): Partner clinic staff with CHN navigator reviewing referrals. | Alt-text: “Partner clinic and CHN navigator coordinating follow-up care.”
SEGMENTATION VARIANTS - EMAIL 2:
Donors with a YE2024 gift on or after 11/01/2024 (campaign code: YE2024) - Subject: You sparked momentum—will you help secure January clinics? - Opening Paragraph: Dear {{FirstName|Friend}}, thank you for your recent gift of {{LastGiftAmount}} on {{LastGiftDate}}. With the match still active through Dec 31, a modest add-on gift—or inviting one friend to give—will help us lock in January Mobile Clinic Days while every dollar is doubled.
Opened at least one YE2024 email but no YE2024 donation recorded - Subject: Your attention matters—your gift will be doubled today - Opening Paragraph: Dear {{FirstName|Friend}}, you have been following these updates. With the match in place and the calendar moving quickly, your first year-end gift will be doubled and immediately applied to screenings and enrollment at upcoming Mobile Clinic Days. Please donate now.
Last gift date between 01/01/2022 and 12/31/2023; no gifts in 2024 - Subject: We built this together—let’s bring more neighbors into care - Opening Paragraph: Dear {{FirstName|Friend}}, your past support helped launch Mobile Clinic Days that enroll neighbors into ongoing care. Since then, our navigator team and partner sites have grown. With the year-end match doubling gifts through Dec 31, your renewal will secure more clinics this winter.
[UNOPENED - Alternative Subject Lines] 1) Help us reach our year-end match for neighbors in need 2) Your gift today schedules tomorrow’s doctor visits 3) Double your impact before the holidays end
Note: Suppress donors who already gave to THIS campaign from receiving this base send (move to thank-you/upgrade/share variant).
Suggested send names/segments: ye2024_e2_base; ye2024_suppress_donors_gave
════════════════════════════════════════════════════
EMAIL 3: FINAL PUSH (Dec 28–31) ════════════════════════════════════════════════════
BASE VERSION:
Subject Line Options: 1) Last chance: make a tax-deductible gift by Dec 31 2) Midnight ET, Dec 31: your gift is doubled until 11:59 p.m. 3) Fund care now—help neighbors start 2025 with a doctor
Preheader: Hours remain to make a tax-deductible, matched gift for uninsured neighbors.
From: Dr. Samuel Ortega, Chief Executive Officer
Opening Hook: Dear {{FirstName|Friend}},
This is our final appeal of 2024. There is still time to open the door to care for a neighbor.
Body: At year’s end, every dollar matters—twice. All gifts are doubled up to $100,000 through Dec 31, 11:59 p.m. ET, thanks to the Carolina Health Foundation. Your tax-deductible gift today will fund screenings and on-site enrollment so neighbors begin 2025 connected to primary care.
Mobile Clinic Days are monthly pop-up clinics that provide screenings and immediate enrollment into ongoing care. Our navigators then follow up until appointments are kept and prescriptions start.
“As a pastor, I watched people leave your clinic with hope and a phone number they could call,” a partner shared. “They weren’t alone anymore.”
Please make a decisive year-end gift: - $50 supports one screening and same-day enrollment - $150 powers navigator follow-up for multiple patients this week - $500 sustains Mobile Clinic Day operations at a community site
Primary CTA (repeat 2–3x with descriptive link text): - Give by Dec 31 to count for 2024 taxes (matched) — https://coastalhealthnav.org/donate?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}} - Donate now to fund January screenings and enrollment — https://coastalhealthnav.org/donate?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}} - Complete your 2024 gift to connect a neighbor to care — https://coastalhealthnav.org/donate?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}}
Countdown/Deadline: Countdown: [XX hours] until Dec 31, 11:59 p.m. ET.
P.S. Coastal Health Navigators is a 501(c)(3). Your gift is tax-deductible as allowed by law and will be doubled if made by 11:59 p.m. Eastern Time tonight.
Signature: Dr. Samuel Ortega Chief Executive Officer
Compliance Footer Notes: - Coastal Health Navigators is a 501(c)(3) organization. Your contribution is tax-deductible as allowed by law.; EIN: [EIN] - Preferences/Unsubscribe: https://coastalhealthnav.org/email-preferences
Image Suggestions: - Placement 1 (header or “final hours” banner): Clean “Final Hours—Matched Through Dec 31” graphic. | Alt-text: “Final hours to give—match active until 11:59 p.m. ET.” - Placement 2 (beneficiary/program impact): Navigator making a follow-up call with appointment card on desk. | Alt-text: “Navigator arranging a primary care appointment for a neighbor.”
SEGMENTATION VARIANTS - EMAIL 3:
Donors with a YE2024 gift on or after 11/01/2024 (campaign code: YE2024) - Subject: With gratitude—one final matched opportunity tonight - Opening Paragraph: Dear {{FirstName|Friend}}, thank you for your recent generosity ({{LastGiftAmount}} on {{LastGiftDate}}). If you wish to make an additional, tax-deductible gift—or share this match with a friend—your support will be doubled through 11:59 p.m. ET and will fund January Mobile Clinic Days.
Opened at least one YE2024 email but no YE2024 donation recorded - Subject: Last chance tonight: matched gift, tax-deductible - Opening Paragraph: Dear {{FirstName|Friend}}, this is the final call. A matched, tax-deductible gift made by 11:59 p.m. ET will connect neighbors to screenings and care at the start of 2025. Please give now.
Last gift date between 01/01/2022 and 12/31/2023; no gifts in 2024 - Subject: We would be honored to welcome you back by midnight - Opening Paragraph: Dear {{FirstName|Friend}}, your past generosity helped launch the services now standing ready for neighbors. If you are able to renew by 11:59 p.m. ET tonight, your tax-deductible gift will be doubled and immediately applied to January clinics.
[UNOPENED - Alternative Subject Lines] 1) Hours left to make a 2024, tax-deductible gift 2) Your year-end gift is doubled until 11:59 p.m. ET 3) Help a neighbor start 2025 with a doctor—give tonight
Note: Suppress donors who already gave to THIS campaign from receiving this base send (move to thank-you/upgrade/share variant).
Suggested send names/segments: ye2024_e3_base; ye2024_suppress_donors_gave
════════════════════════════════════════════════════
Additional Implementation Notes
- Tone and voice: FORMAL throughout. - All CTAs link to https://coastalhealthnav.org/donate with this tracking: ?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}} - Recommended {{EmailName}} values by segment: - ye2024_e1_base; ye2024_e1_donors_gave; ye2024_e1_opened; ye2024_e1_lapsed; ye2024_e1_unopened - ye2024_e2_base; ye2024_suppress_donors_gave - ye2024_e3_base; ye2024_suppress_donors_gave - Personalization: - Use {{FirstName|Friend}} in salutations. - If available, reference {{LastGiftAmount}} on {{LastGiftDate}} in donor-thanks variants. - Deadline/time zone: All messages anchor to Dec 31, 11:59 p.m. Eastern Time (ET). - Suppression: - Donors who already gave to the YE2024 campaign should be suppressed from base sends of Emails 2–3 and receive a thank-you/upgrade/share variant instead.
AI Evaluation Details (Score: 8.4/10)
This is a highly professional, well-structured year-end campaign that demonstrates strong command of fundraising best practices and the formal tone requested. The output is immediately usable with minimal edits, though there are minor inconsistencies in gift amounts and a few areas where personalization could be smoother.
- • Excellent tone consistency: The formal voice is maintained throughout without becoming stiff—uses restrained language ('decisive year-end gift,' 'we would be honored') appropriate for a health nonprofit addressing institutional and individual donors
- • Comprehensive segmentation strategy: All four variants are provided for each email with thoughtful customization that addresses donor psychology (gratitude for recent givers, acknowledgment for openers, warm re-welcome for lapsed)
- • Strong storytelling within constraints: Maria's story in Email 1 and the partner quotes throughout provide concrete, human examples without melodrama, fitting the formal tone
- • Excellent structural adherence: Follows the template precisely with all required elements (subject lines, preheaders, CTAs, P.S. lines, image suggestions with alt-text, compliance footer)
- • Smart urgency escalation: The arc from invitational (Email 1) to momentum-driven (Email 2) to final deadline (Email 3) is well-calibrated and avoids guilt-based framing
- • Professional CTA construction: Link text is descriptive and outcome-focused ('Give $50 to support one screening and same-day enrollment') rather than generic
- • Practical implementation details: UTM parameters, CRM tag suggestions, and suppression rules are clearly documented
- • Mobile-friendly formatting: Short paragraphs, scannable structure, clear hierarchy throughout
- • Gift amount inconsistency: The prompt specifies $50/$120/$300 tied to specific outcomes, but Email 1 uses $50/$150/$500, and these amounts shift across emails without clear rationale—this could confuse donors and complicate backend tracking
- • Missing impact statistic: The prompt provides '82% of clients were matched with a primary care provider within 30 days' but this concrete stat is never used; instead, the emails rely on quotes and general program descriptions
- • Beneficiary quote attribution mismatch: Email 1 uses 'Maria' in the narrative but the provided quote is attributed to 'Denise, Beaufort County'—creates a minor continuity issue
- • Word count slightly under target: Email bodies appear to be 180-220 words rather than the requested 200-300, though this is a minor issue and the brevity may actually improve performance
- • Merge field notation inconsistency: Uses {{FirstName|Friend}} in some places and [FIRST NAME|Friend] in others within the same document, though the scenario specifies the double-brace format
- • EIN display error: The compliance footer shows 'EIN: [EIN]' instead of the actual number (27-1045839) provided in the scenario—a small but important oversight for legal compliance
Large Established Org
National education nonprofit improving early literacy in Title I schools; broad base of individual donors plus corporate partners.
View scenario details
EMAIL 1: STORY-DRIVEN CASE FOR SUPPORT (Dec 1–10) ════════════════════════════════════════════════════
BASE VERSION:
Subject Line Options: 1) A child found her voice in a book—help the next one 2) December starts strong: triple your impact for young readers 3) “Can I read this to my sister?” — a moment you can spark
Preheader: Your gift this month is TRIPLED to help more kids read by third grade.
From: Marisol Vega, Chief Advancement Officer
Opening Hook: {{FirstName|Friend}}, a second grader named Maya stacked three “just-right” books in her backpack. She whispered, “I get to read these to Grandma tonight.”
Body: This is what you power at EveryKid Reads. We help children in under-resourced schools read on grade level by third grade through 1:1 tutoring, family literacy workshops, and classroom resources.
Here’s the momentum your gift unlocks: last year, 82% of students who met weekly with our Reading Coaches gained two or more reading levels. And this December, your gift goes three times as far—every donation is TRIPLED, up to $500,000 through Dec 31, 11:59 p.m. ET, thanks to PageTurner Publishing.
“As soon as he had someone beside him, he believed he could read,” a teacher told us. “Now Jamal volunteers to read aloud. He even takes a book home to share with his little sister. That confidence spills into everything.”
Program example: Reading Coaches in Classrooms pairs trained volunteers with students for weekly 1:1 sessions. Coaches send home book bundles so reading continues after school—around dinner tables, bus rides, and bedtime.
Primary CTA (repeat 2–3x with descriptive link text): - Give $35 to send a book bundle home with a young reader — https://everykidreads.org/donate?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}} - Give $150 to fund a month of 1:1 tutoring for one child — https://everykidreads.org/donate?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}} - Give $500 to equip a classroom reading corner for the year — https://everykidreads.org/donate?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}}
Countdown/Deadline: Countdown: ~30 days to Dec 31, 11:59 p.m. ET. Your gift is tripled all month.
P.S. Thank you for starting December with hope. When you give now, you put more “just-right” books into eager hands—and your gift is tripled.
Signature: Marisol Vega Chief Advancement Officer
Compliance Footer Notes: - EveryKid Reads is a 501(c)(3) public charity. Donations are tax-deductible to the fullest extent of the law.; EIN: 11-6029384 - Preferences/Unsubscribe: https://everykidreads.org/email-preferences
Image Suggestions: - Placement 1 (header): Smiling student holding a book bundle in a classroom | Alt-text: “Second grader smiling and holding a take-home book bundle” - Placement 2 (mid-body optional): Tutor and student reading together at a small table | Alt-text: “Reading Coach in a 1:1 session with a student”
Tracking/Naming Notes: - Suggested {{EmailName}} value: ye2024_e1_base - Suggested segment names: ye2024_e1_base; ye2024_e1_donors_gave; ye2024_e1_opened; ye2024_e1_lapsed; ye2024_e1_unopened
SEGMENTATION VARIANTS - EMAIL 1:
Any donor with a recorded YE2024 gift since 11/01/2024 (Campaign ID: YE2024) - Subject: Your recent gift is already opening books—thank you - Opening Paragraph: {{FirstName|Friend}}, thank you for your generous gift{{LastGiftAmount}} on {{LastGiftDate}}. You’ve already put more books and 1:1 tutoring within reach for kids who need it most. If you’re able, a small year-end “booster” gift—or sharing this campaign with a friend—will help us fully unlock the triple match by Dec 31.
Opened at least one YE2024 message but has no YE2024 transaction - Subject: You’ve been reading—will you help a child read, too? - Opening Paragraph: We noticed you’ve been following our updates—thank you. With the triple match live all month, your first gift will be tripled and can fund a month of 1:1 tutoring right away. Will you donate today so more students start the new year on track?
Last gift between 12 and 36 months ago; no donations in 2024 - Subject: You helped build this—here’s what your support can do now - Opening Paragraph: {{FirstName|Friend}}, your past support helped us launch Reading Coaches in Classrooms. Since then, more students are moving up reading levels each semester. This December, every gift is tripled through Dec 31—will you rejoin us so more children enter third grade ready to read?
[UNOPENED - Alternative Subject Lines] 1) A good book changes everything for a child—help us share more 2) Triple match unlocked: your December gift goes 3x as far 3) The moment a child says “I can read this” starts with you
════════════════════════════════════════════════════
EMAIL 2: URGENCY + SOCIAL PROOF (Dec 15–23) ════════════════════════════════════════════════════
BASE VERSION:
Subject Line Options: 1) We’re moving—help us unlock the full triple match by Dec 31 2) Join 1,000+ neighbors investing in young readers this month 3) Your gift today is tripled—let’s keep the pages turning
Preheader: Momentum check: triple match active through Dec 31, 11:59 p.m. ET.
From: Marisol Vega, Chief Advancement Officer
Opening Hook: The pages are turning quickly, {{FirstName|Friend}}. Supporters across the country are rallying so more children start January reading with confidence.
Body: Thanks to early gifts this month, we’re on pace to unlock our full triple match—every donation is tripled up to $500,000 through Dec 31, 11:59 p.m. ET, thanks to PageTurner Publishing. Will you add your name to the community of supporters today?
Weekly, 1:1 tutoring works. Students in our coaching program average more than a grade level of reading growth in a school year, and many accelerate even faster with consistent sessions and take-home books.
“My second graders can’t wait for ‘coach day,’” a partner teacher shared. “Twenty minutes of undivided attention changes their week. I see confidence grow line by line.”
What your gift makes possible right now: Reading Coaches in Classrooms pairs trained volunteers with students for weekly tutoring and sends home book bundles so practice continues after school and over winter break.
Primary CTA (repeat 2–3x with descriptive link text): - Donate $35 to send a winter-break book bundle home — https://everykidreads.org/donate?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}} - Donate $150 to fund a month of 1:1 tutoring for one student — https://everykidreads.org/donate?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}} - Donate $500 to equip a classroom reading corner for the year — https://everykidreads.org/donate?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}}
Countdown/Deadline: Countdown: ~8–16 days to Dec 31, 11:59 p.m. ET. Triple match active now.
P.S. Your timely gift helps keep our match on track. Donate today and your impact is tripled for young readers when it matters most.
Signature: Marisol Vega Chief Advancement Officer
Compliance Footer Notes: - EveryKid Reads is a 501(c)(3) public charity. Donations are tax-deductible to the fullest extent of the law.; EIN: 11-6029384 - Preferences/Unsubscribe: https://everykidreads.org/email-preferences
Image Suggestions: - Placement 1 (header or progress graphic): Simple progress bar showing “Triple Match: On Track” | Alt-text: “Progress toward unlocking the $500,000 triple match” - Placement 2 (pull-quote or program action shot): Teacher and student smiling during read-aloud | Alt-text: “Teacher celebrating a student’s reading progress”
Tracking/Naming Notes: - Suggested {{EmailName}} value: ye2024_e2_base - Suggested segment names: ye2024_e2_base; ye2024_suppress_donors_gave
SEGMENTATION VARIANTS - EMAIL 2:
Any donor with a recorded YE2024 gift since 11/01/2024 (Campaign ID: YE2024) - Subject: You’re fueling this momentum—thank you - Opening Paragraph: {{FirstName|Friend}}, your gift{{LastGiftAmount}} on {{LastGiftDate}} is moving us closer to unlocking the full triple match. If you’re able, consider a small “match-maker” add-on—or share this message with a friend so we finish strong by Dec 31.
Opened at least one YE2024 message but has no YE2024 transaction - Subject: The triple match is active—will you take the next step? - Opening Paragraph: You’ve been with us in the inbox—thank you for caring. The triple match ends Dec 31. Your first gift today is tripled and can put tutoring time and books in a child’s hands right away. Please donate now.
Last gift between 12 and 36 months ago; no donations in 2024 - Subject: We’d love to welcome you back—your gift is tripled - Opening Paragraph: You helped lay the foundation for Reading Coaches in Classrooms. Today, more students are gaining reading levels—and your renewed support will be tripled through Dec 31. We’d be honored to have you back this season.
[UNOPENED - Alternative Subject Lines] 1) This week: your gift is tripled for young readers 2) Help unlock every dollar by Dec 31, 11:59 p.m. ET 3) A quick December update—and an easy way to help kids read
Note: Suppress donors who already gave to THIS campaign from receiving this base send (move to thank-you/upgrade/share variant).
════════════════════════════════════════════════════
EMAIL 3: FINAL PUSH (Dec 28–31) ════════════════════════════════════════════════════
BASE VERSION:
Subject Line Options: 1) Last chance: make your 2024 tax-deductible gift by midnight 2) Ends Dec 31, 11:59 p.m. ET: triple match + tax benefits 3) Fund a month of tutoring now so a child starts 2025 strong
Preheader: Final hours: your gift is tax-deductible and TRIPLED through Dec 31.
From: Marisol Vega, Chief Advancement Officer
Opening Hook: This is it, {{FirstName|Friend}}—the final days to make a 2024, tax-deductible gift that is also TRIPLED for young readers.
Body: We’re close to unlocking every match dollar by Dec 31, 11:59 p.m. ET. If you’ve been considering a year-end gift, please act now. Thanks to PageTurner Publishing, every donation is tripled up to $500,000—fueling 1:1 tutoring, family literacy workshops, and classroom resources in under-resourced schools.
One concrete outcome: across our sites last year, 7 in 10 second graders finished the year on or above grade level after consistent coaching. Reading Coaches in Classrooms pairs trained volunteers with students each week and sends home book bundles so practice continues into the new year.
“I watched Mateo go from guessing at words to decoding with a smile,” a volunteer coach shared. “He asked to take the book home to read to his dad on New Year’s Eve. That’s the spark we’re after.”
Your timely gift tonight funds time, books, and encouragement a child can hold. And it’s tax-deductible to the fullest extent of the law.
Primary CTA (repeat 2–3x with descriptive link text): - Give by Dec 31 for a 2024 tax deduction (tripled today) — https://everykidreads.org/donate?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}} - Donate now to fund January tutoring sessions — https://everykidreads.org/donate?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}} - Complete your 2024 gift and send home book bundles — https://everykidreads.org/donate?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}}
Countdown/Deadline: Countdown: Final hours—through Dec 31, 11:59 p.m. ET. Triple match ends at midnight Eastern.
P.S. Thank you for every page you’ve helped turn this year. Gifts made before Dec 31, 11:59 p.m. ET are tax-deductible for 2024—and tripled for kids learning to read.
Signature: Marisol Vega Chief Advancement Officer
Compliance Footer Notes: - EveryKid Reads is a 501(c)(3) public charity. Donations are tax-deductible to the fullest extent of the law.; EIN: 11-6029384 - Preferences/Unsubscribe: https://everykidreads.org/email-preferences
Image Suggestions: - Placement 1 (header or “final hours” banner): Simple “Final Hours: Triple Match Ends Dec 31, 11:59 p.m. ET” graphic | Alt-text: “Final hours banner for triple match deadline” - Placement 2 (beneficiary/program impact): Parent and child reading together at home with a book bundle | Alt-text: “Caregiver and child reading a take-home book together”
Tracking/Naming Notes: - Suggested {{EmailName}} value: ye2024_e3_base - Suggested segment names: ye2024_e3_base; ye2024_suppress_donors_gave
SEGMENTATION VARIANTS - EMAIL 3:
Any donor with a recorded YE2024 gift since 11/01/2024 (Campaign ID: YE2024) - Subject: With gratitude—one last note before midnight - Opening Paragraph: Thank you, {{FirstName|Friend}}. Your gift{{LastGiftAmount}} on {{LastGiftDate}} is fueling tutoring and book bundles right away. If you’d like to do a little more before midnight—or share this match with a friend—this is the last window to triple your impact and receive 2024 tax credit.
Opened at least one YE2024 message but has no YE2024 transaction - Subject: Final hours to give in 2024—triple match ends at midnight ET - Opening Paragraph: You’ve stayed with us through December. Tonight is the last chance: your gift before 11:59 p.m. ET is tax-deductible and tripled. Please make your 2024 gift now so children start January with tutoring and books in hand.
Last gift between 12 and 36 months ago; no donations in 2024 - Subject: Welcome back for one last 2024 gift—tripled by midnight - Opening Paragraph: We’d be honored to welcome you back before the year ends. Your renewed gift—made by 11:59 p.m. ET—will be tax-deductible and tripled, supporting weekly coaching and take-home books right at the start of the new year.
[UNOPENED - Alternative Subject Lines] 1) Hours left: make a 2024, tax-deductible gift that’s tripled 2) Midnight ET: last chance to fund tutoring in January 3) Don’t miss the match: help a child read by third grade
Note: Suppress donors who already gave to THIS campaign from receiving this base send (move to thank-you/upgrade/share variant).
════════════════════════════════════════════════════
Additional Implementation Notes - Mission anchor: “We help children in under-resourced schools read on grade level by third grade through 1:1 tutoring, family literacy workshops, and classroom resources.” appears in Email 1 and is reinforced throughout. - Matching gift: “All gifts tripled up to $500,000 through Dec 31, 11:59 p.m. ET, thanks to PageTurner Publishing.” appears in all emails to sustain urgency. - Suggested gift amounts/outcomes (used across CTAs): - $35 sends a take-home book bundle to a young reader. - $150 funds a month of weekly 1:1 tutoring for one student. - $500 equips a classroom reading corner for a year. - Tracking: All CTAs use https://everykidreads.org/donate?utm_source=email&utm_medium=appeal&utm_campaign=ye2024&utm_content={{EmailName}}. Set {{EmailName}} per segment as suggested. - Segments/naming to prevent duplicate asks: ye2024_e1_base; ye2024_e1_donors_gave; ye2024_e1_opened; ye2024_e1_lapsed; ye2024_e1_unopened; ye2024_e2_base; ye2024_e3_base; ye2024_suppress_donors_gave. - Preferences: Include https://everykidreads.org/email-preferences in footer of each send. - Compliance: Include “EveryKid Reads is a 501(c)(3) public charity. Donations are tax-deductible to the fullest extent of the law.; EIN: 11-6029384” in each email (at minimum present in Email 3; included in all above).
AI Evaluation Details (Score: 8.8/10)
This is an exceptionally strong, production-ready fundraising campaign that demonstrates deep understanding of nonprofit email best practices. The copy is warm, concrete, and donor-centered with excellent narrative flow across the three-email arc. Minor inconsistencies in gift amounts and some mechanical elements prevent a perfect score, but this would require minimal editing before deployment.
- • Excellent narrative arc with authentic storytelling—Maya's backpack moment and Mateo reading to his dad on New Year's Eve are memorable, human, and avoid clichés
- • Strong adherence to warm tone throughout—gracious, plainspoken, never guilt-based, with natural conversational rhythm
- • Comprehensive segmentation variants that are genuinely differentiated and strategically sound, especially the 'already gave' variants that offer upgrade/share options
- • Concrete, scannable copy with short paragraphs, varied sentence length, and mobile-friendly structure throughout
- • Excellent CTA variety and specificity—link text is descriptive and outcome-focused ('Give $150 to fund a month of 1:1 tutoring') rather than generic
- • Strong use of social proof in Email 2 ('Join 1,000+ neighbors') and credible impact statistics (82% gained two levels, 7 in 10 on grade level)
- • Appropriate escalation of urgency from Email 1 (invitational) to Email 3 (confident, deadline-focused) without becoming shrill
- • Thoughtful image suggestions with proper alt-text that enhance accessibility
- • Complete tracking infrastructure with UTM parameters and CRM tag suggestions
- • P.S. lines are strategic and varied—reinforcing match, gratitude, or urgency as appropriate to each email's purpose
- • Gift amount inconsistency: Email 1 uses '$35 to send a book bundle' but the scenario specified $40 for '10 new books to a classroom'—the AI changed amounts without explanation and the outcomes don't match the original spec
- • Email 1 body is slightly under 200 words (~180-190 depending on merge field resolution), though still effective
- • The 'Countdown/Deadline' sections use placeholder language ('~30 days,' '~8-16 days') rather than dynamic merge syntax or clearer implementation guidance for email platforms
- • Minor redundancy: 'tax-deductible' appears in both the final CTA link text and the P.S. of Email 3, which could be streamlined
Test Summary: Generated Nov 2, 2025 • 3 scenarios • 9 total outputs • Average quality score: 8.29/10 • Total validation cost: $0.6605